YouTube killed clickbait

I just got hit by a silent algorithm penalty.

9% clickthrough rate.
Zero distribution.

The title? Too sensational.

That’s when it clicked: platforms don’t want clickbait anymore. They want trust.

Here’s what I’m seeing right now:

1. Clicks ≠ revenue
Back in the Digg/Reddit days, I chased traffic. Sensational headlines worked.
But they didn’t convert.

Attention without intent is a vanity metric.
If your content overpromises, you might win the click—but you lose the customer.

2. Packaging is getting filtered
YouTube is cracking down hard.
If your title feels exaggerated, polarizing, or even slightly misleading, you get throttled.

The algorithm is optimizing for satisfaction, not curiosity.

3. AI is making content worse (if you’re lazy)
You can spot AI-written content instantly now:

• Overly “punchy” statements

• Fake contrarian takes

Most of it sounds impressive. None of it builds trust.

If everyone sounds the same, nobody stands out.

4. Great marketing starts with great people
Years ago, an investor told me something I ignored for too long:

Your #1 job is hiring.

Not traffic. Not leads. Not growth hacks.

If you have the right people, they solve everything else.
If you don’t, nothing works—no matter how good your strategy is.

5. Data before decisions
The best marketers don’t rush to make changes.

They:

• Study what’s already working

• Analyze data deeply (AI helps here)

• Then make informed moves

Fast decisions without context = expensive mistakes.

6. Money doesn’t fix misalignment
I’ve seen $6M+ offers. Turned them down.

If you’re not aligned with what you’re doing, the money doesn’t matter.
It fades fast.

Long-term success comes from doing work you actually want to win at.

Learn more by watching this video.

The game has changed. It’s no longer about hacking attention.
It’s about earning it—everywhere.

That’s exactly why we built Search Everywhere Optimization (SEvO) at Single Grain.

It’s not just SEO anymore.
It’s about showing up across AI search, YouTube, social, and beyond.

If you’re not visible everywhere your audience searches, you’re invisible.

To building real leverage,
Eric Siu

P.S.

1 - If you want to grow faster using the power of AI, my agency Single Grain is offering free marketing plans to qualified Leveling Up newsletter subscribers, check it out here.
2 - We’re hiring AI-forward performance ad creative strategists, AI-forward SEOs and paid media people, AI short form creators, AI automation interns, and more. If you’re interested, apply at our Careers page.
3 - We launched ClickFlow to help automate and scale SEO.
4 - Interested in creating 1:1 personalized LinkedIn ads in minutes instead of weeks? Sign up for the Karrot.ai waitlist.
5 - For more in-depth marketing content, check out my Leveling Up YouTube channel
6 - To help this newsletter improve, fill out this survey